Cubic Enigma


$M$ and $N$ are two positive integers where $M$ is not equal to $N$. LCM of $(M$ and $N) = M^2 - N^2 + MN$. Show that $MN$ is a perfect cubic number.


Source: BdMO 2019 National Junior P8


Proof Based Problems  


  2 Upvotes                    0 Downvotes


Solution

Disclaimer: The solutions we've shared are just one exciting approach, and there are surely many other wonderful methods out there. We’d love to hear your alternative solutions in the community thread below, so let's keep the creativity flowing!

Let the gcd of $M$ and $N$ be $d$.

Let $M=dm$ and $N=dn$.
As $d$ is gcd, $gcd(m,n)=1$

So as given $lcm(M,N)=M^2-N^2+MN$

$lcm(M,N)=d^2m^2-d^2n^2+d^2mn=d^2(m^2-n^2+mn)$


We know, $gcd(a,b) \times lcm(a,b)=ab$

Using this,

$lcm(M,N) \times gcd(M,N)=MN$

$d^2(m^2-n^2+mn) \times d = dm \times dn$

$d^3(m^2-n^2+mn)=d^2mn$

$d(m^2-n^2+mn)=mn$

$dm^2-dn^2+dmn=mn$

$mn(d-1)=d(n^2-m^2)=d(n-m)(n+m)$


Note that $d$ is a divisor of Left hand side

As $gcd(d,d-1)=1$ and $d | mn(d-1)$ we have $d | mn$

As $gcd(m,n)=1$ 

So, $gcd(m,n-m)=1$


Also $gcd(m,n+m)=1$

So, $gcd(m,(n-m)(n+m))=1$


Similarly $gcd(n,(n-m)(n+m))=1$

So, $gcd(mn,(n-m)(n+m))=1$

which implies $mn | d$


We have $d | mn$ and $mn | d$ so $d=mn$

Now, $MN=dm \times dn =d^2mn=d^3$ which is a cubic number.

This is a proof based problem added for learning purposes and does not accept submissions.

You can view the solution by clicking on the solution tab.

Editorial



Need a hint? Checkout the editorial.

View Editorial